News RSS Feed


School rethinks halal menu plan

8:14am Wednesday 20th February 2008

comment Comments (30)   Have your say »


AN Oxford primary school has rethought a plan to serve only halal meat.

Rose Hill Primary School used halal meat, which is slaughtered under Muslim religious law, in several dishes last year and in all meat dishes for a month-long trial last month.

It was the first school in the county to ask school meals provider Food with Thought to provide a purely halal menu.

The school has now decided to offer youngsters a choice of normal meat, a halal option or a vegetarian dish, and will use a wristband system to make sure pupils get the correct meal.

Lyndsy Johnson, 35, of Radford Close, said: "We're glad now that we have got the three options. That is how it should have been to start off with.

"It was a very big issue. Everyone was talking about it on the estate. We have definitely got parent power."

Parents only found out about the menu change on the last day of winter term - after halal meat had begun to be served.

Some parents were opposed to their children eating halal food, because they felt the animals were slaughtered in a cruel way. They said they should have been consulted about the changes.

Within days parents raised a petition with 220 signatures, calling for three choices for school meals - meat, halal meat and vegetarian - and met headteacher Sue Mortimer and school governors to discuss their concerns.

On February 8, Mrs Mortimer sent home a letter which read: "Whilst the trial was on I continued to have discussions with Food with Thought and am now able to confirm the school could have three choices at lunchtime."

The new menus will begin on Monday, with children at the school in The Oval choosing meals at morning registration.

They will be given coloured wristbands to show dinner ladies their choice for the day, with a red wristband for meat, blue for halal meat and green for vegetarian.

Mrs Mortimer had told parents the school introduced halal meat as part of its inclusion policy.

She said because halal meat was not forbidden by any religion or culture it would allow every pupil to choose a meat dish for lunch.

She refused to comment on the new system.

A spokesman for Oxfordshire County Council said the school had bought new equipment to ensure halal meat and non-halal meat was kept separate during preparation.

Dr Taj Hargey, chairman of the Muslim Education Centre of Oxford, said: "This is the best solution to improving community relations."


Your Say YourOxford

Imran, oxford says...
9:11am Wed 20 Feb 08

I think this should have been done before instead of making the whole menu halal which caused all the protest. This is a multiculture society and Oxford is a good example of this for the rest of the UK. Peace.

simon, out there... says...
9:29am Wed 20 Feb 08

Perhaps the silly PC moo in charge of the school would like to introduce sharia law and have compulsory prayer times for all during the school day for all pupils to be 'inclusive' with regard to islam! We are NOT a multicultural society. We are a white anglo-saxon society which allows people of other cultures etc, to settle here if they choose to do so( with criteria followed-usually). I find it odd that those from 'other cultures' in their own countries are NOT so welcoming to incomers with their own cultures and belief systems. 'We' are a little too understanding- and a more agressive approach to incomers with regard to our laws, customs, and belief system is required. Peace.

MIKE, oxford says...
9:35am Wed 20 Feb 08

Well said Simon !! We certainly are not a multicultural society. Yes our society is built from white anglo-saxon folk who have allowed people of other cultures to settle here. Dead right mate.

Web Watcher, West Oxon says...
9:56am Wed 20 Feb 08

I believe it is still the law that all state schools (apart from church controlled or voluntary managed schools) are required to hold a daily non-denominational worship. However I think this is seldom practiced in today's schools as it was 50 years ago.

Imran, oxford says...
10:13am Wed 20 Feb 08

simon wrote:
Perhaps the silly PC moo in charge of the school would like to introduce sharia law and have compulsory prayer times for all during the school day for all pupils to be 'inclusive' with regard to islam! We are NOT a multicultural society. We are a white anglo-saxon society which allows people of other cultures etc, to settle here if they choose to do so( with criteria followed-usually). I find it odd that those from 'other cultures' in their own countries are NOT so welcoming to incomers with their own cultures and belief systems. 'We' are a little too understanding- and a more agressive approach to incomers with regard to our laws, customs, and belief system is required. Peace.
ok...

Mabs, Oxford says...
10:57am Wed 20 Feb 08

"Perhaps the silly PC moo in charge of the school would like to introduce sharia law and have compulsory prayer times for all during the school day for all pupils to be 'inclusive' with regard to islam! We are NOT a multicultural society. We are a white anglo-saxon society which allows people of other cultures etc, to settle here if they choose to do so( with criteria followed-usually). I find it odd that those from 'other cultures' in their own countries are NOT so welcoming to incomers with their own cultures and belief systems. 'We' are a little too understanding- and a more agressive approach to incomers with regard to our laws, customs, and belief system is required. Peace"

Well Well arn't we angry angry ? don't forget the colonial past of this country and how non "white anglo saxon socities" were exploited and there resources exploited and indigenious people abused to bring riches Great Britain. Lets not talk about the slave trade, or Australian aborigies or New Zealand maoris or North Ameraican indians. Or the blase carving up of the middle east or the Indian subcontinent.(not to mention the things done in Africa)
The chickens coming home to roost and you will live in a multicultural society whether you like it or not, we are here to stay and we will abide by your laws but we will keep our culture.
Maybe if you left the world alone we would not be here ?
Read a bit of history before sterio typing.

Ed, Oxford says...
10:58am Wed 20 Feb 08

We're not multicultural, we're multi-racial.

There is and can only one culture in Britain: British.

If you're born here, you're British. If you weren't, you become accustomed to Britishness until you are British. End of story.

simon, out there... says...
11:05am Wed 20 Feb 08

I knew the PC 'wasn't slavery BAD' brigade would be out! Our society has moved on since the times of slavery 'mabs'- unlike certain 'ethnic' cultures abroad! Justifying immigration etc, by bringing up slavery is no argument at all. You know the position regarding immigration into this country- that's why you're getting 'angry/upset'- it has NEVER been voted on by the people- and we all know why that is. And btw- i have a degree in History! I take NO lectures from you at all.

Imran, oxford says...
11:22am Wed 20 Feb 08

simon wrote:
I knew the PC 'wasn't slavery BAD' brigade would be out! Our society has moved on since the times of slavery 'mabs'- unlike certain 'ethnic' cultures abroad! Justifying immigration etc, by bringing up slavery is no argument at all. You know the position regarding immigration into this country- that's why you're getting 'angry/upset'- it has NEVER been voted on by the people- and we all know why that is. And btw- i have a degree in History! I take NO lectures from you at all.
ok...

Imran, Oxford says...
11:24am Wed 20 Feb 08

Ed wrote:
We're not multicultural, we're multi-racial.

There is and can only one culture in Britain: British.

If you're born here, you're British. If you weren't, you become accustomed to Britishness until you are British. End of story.
well said.

DanOxford, Oxford says...
11:54am Wed 20 Feb 08

Mabs- some white middle class apologist hand wringers may feel that post- colonial guilt is reason enough to allow British culture to be completely undermined, or- as some would have us believe- removed without trace as if it never existed amongst lies such as 'England has always ben a nation of immigrants' (that so? Compare and contrast any photo of any public event pre- 1950 with one taking place today; explain why immigration is now TWENTY FIVE times any level in British history) but the majority do not and have an absolute right to feel proud of all the amazing things Britain has done and given the World.

I haven't personally been involved in the slave trade, exploiting other countries' resources or putting down insurrections in some far off region, and nor were any of my family, so I don't feel compelled to bow my head, shuffle my shoes and mumble an apologetic acceptance that the ango- saxon majority in this Country should accept being turned into second class citizens.

The tide has turned against multi-culturalism in it's current form, and rightly so. Many of the 'cultural' traditions we have tolerated are only forms of exclusion which prevent integration anyway- arranged marriages; importing spouses; restrictive dietary practices; faith schools; religions that proclaim they are The One True Faith; providing translation services- the list goes on. All of these are discriminatory but hide behind the cries of 'racism!' whenever they're attacked for the divisive nonsense that they truly are.

Mabs, Oxford says...
12:03pm Wed 20 Feb 08

"I knew the PC 'wasn't slavery BAD' brigade would be out! Our society has moved on since the times of slavery 'mabs'- unlike certain 'ethnic' cultures abroad! Justifying immigration etc, by bringing up slavery is no argument at all. You know the position regarding immigration into this country- that's why you're getting 'angry/upset'- it has NEVER been voted on by the people- and we all know why that is. And btw- i have a degree in History! I take NO lectures from you at all"

If you really have a degree in history you would now all about the indiscretions of the colonial past.
I'm not angry btw, i'm smiling at your squirming, and just to rub in, I'm non white British and my kids are non white and British and born here and we love it here, we work hard pay tax at 40% band and claim no benefits.
My parents lived in Tanzania as did many ethnic south Asians, (originally shipped over for slavery in Africa, but you know all about History so I won't lecture you.
AND the British government advertised on the radio for people to come over and live in England and work in your factories and help you prosper, AND being a British colony we did not even need a VISA !
Love it ! So we came and we contributed and settled down and just cause we want to preserve our own culture you can't hack it.
Now we have contributed and still contribute, yet you are still not happy.
Well I look forward to many more generation of non white hard working coloured people adding to the great ethnic and religious diversity of this wonderful multi cultural and multi racial country.
It looks like the West will be going East soon as India and China prosper so don't worry too much in the long run we will probably be one big melting pot.
People like you will have to get use to it.


simon, out there... says...
12:17pm Wed 20 Feb 08

I'm not squirming! I'm surprised you haven't called me a RACIST yet- always the defense of somebody who has lost the argument. Of course, you tell me about 'history' of slavery etc, but if you knew anything about this country- slavery was in-force well before the colonisation! Try and read about the period regarding industrialisation, and before. Child slavery, adult slavery, all uncoloured, unethnic, that's what our own was doing to our own! What you and your type are arguing for is not equality, but special treatment above white's! You undermine the very notion of a multi-cultural/equal society by your own utterings! WHO is the racist? i suspect you! Try again!

Bill, Oxford says...
12:34pm Wed 20 Feb 08

I'm with Mabs ...

J, Oxford says...
12:35pm Wed 20 Feb 08

Mrs Mortimer had told parents the school introduced halal meat as part of its inclusion policy.

She said because halal meat was not forbidden by any religion or culture it would allow every pupil to choose a meat dish for lunch.



Well Mrs Mortimer is a bit naive then, because although I eat meat, I only eat meat that has been raised in humane conditions, and killed in a humane way, so under no circumstances would I eat Halal meat, as the method of killing it is babaric and cruel.

Just because I'm not religious, doesn't mean I don't have morals and rights too!!

anon, ox says...
2:01pm Wed 20 Feb 08

I totally agree with simon.
I am reading a book and a phrase recently popped up

"wiping out the local population by sheer weight of numbers. Its a new form of genocide. Genocide by overwhelming immigration" this is what is happening to Britain.

Mabs, Oxford says...
2:07pm Wed 20 Feb 08

"I'm not squirming! I'm surprised you haven't called me a RACIST yet- always the defense of somebody who has lost the argument. Of course, you tell me about 'history' of slavery etc, but if you knew anything about this country- slavery was in-force well before the colonisation! Try and read about the period regarding industrialisation, and before. Child slavery, adult slavery, all uncoloured, unethnic, that's what our own was doing to our own! What you and your type are arguing for is not equality, but special treatment above white's! You undermine the very notion of a multi-cultural/equal society by your own utterings! WHO is the racist? i suspect you! Try again!"

I didn't call you a racist even though you said and I quote you "You know the position regarding immigration into this country- that's why you're getting 'angry/upset'- it has NEVER been voted on by the people- and we all know why that is"

So what sort of connotations does that conjure up ???? I don't need to call you a racist !

Anyway I've got work to do, so I'll leave you with one last point.
The person who asked for halal school meals and decided to implement it, was that a decision by the muslim community ? did they ask for it ? did they demand it ? Did muslims ever say they were offended by nativity plays ?
etc etc
NO it was probably some non mulism council/school official who made the decision and that winds people like you up.
All we want is to to live here as equals and if we are muslim or any religion then it is our business as long as we live within the law and don't impose our beliefs or make demands on the majority community.
I would think that the vast vast majority of British people are happy with this.
Pity you are not so enlightened.
All the Best and good day.

Furious, warwickshire says...
2:40pm Wed 20 Feb 08

Mabs wrote:
"I'm not squirming! I'm surprised you haven't called me a RACIST yet- always the defense of somebody who has lost the argument. Of course, you tell me about 'history' of slavery etc, but if you knew anything about this country- slavery was in-force well before the colonisation! Try and read about the period regarding industrialisation, and before. Child slavery, adult slavery, all uncoloured, unethnic, that's what our own was doing to our own! What you and your type are arguing for is not equality, but special treatment above white's! You undermine the very notion of a multi-cultural/equal society by your own utterings! WHO is the racist? i suspect you! Try again!" I didn't call you a racist even though you said and I quote you "You know the position regarding immigration into this country- that's why you're getting 'angry/upset'- it has NEVER been voted on by the people- and we all know why that is" So what sort of connotations does that conjure up ???? I don't need to call you a racist ! Anyway I've got work to do, so I'll leave you with one last point. The person who asked for halal school meals and decided to implement it, was that a decision by the muslim community ? did they ask for it ? did they demand it ? Did muslims ever say they were offended by nativity plays ? etc etc NO it was probably some non mulism council/school official who made the decision and that winds people like you up. All we want is to to live here as equals and if we are muslim or any religion then it is our business as long as we live within the law and don't impose our beliefs or make demands on the majority community. I would think that the vast vast majority of British people are happy with this. Pity you are not so enlightened. All the Best and good day.
The truth is many of you don't live within the law, DO impose on our children and make huge demands on our communities and you could not be more wrong when you say that the majority of British people are happy with it. If you truly believe that then you are truly deluded. The real truth is the pc police ( usually the dumber members of white society) are keeping the others from speaking out for fear of being called racist. If all the people could speak out anonymously without fear of retribution I believe you would hear very differently from what you think you know.
And for the record.....
Do not think that you can post the kind of threats that you have done and not get a neagtive response. I quote "The chickens coming home to roost and you will live in a multicultural society whether you like it or not, we are here to stay and we will abide by your laws but we will keep our culture."
And we Sir shall keep ours and we shall fight for it whether you like it or not. I think that you will also find that hostility regarding these things is growing in the green and pleasant land which you enjoy so freely. Be warned, the times will change.

belle, uk says...
2:53pm Wed 20 Feb 08

Furious, warwickshire .
Couldn't have said it better.

John Radford, says...
2:56pm Wed 20 Feb 08

The 'prophet' of Islam was a mass murderer, multiple rapist, bigamist with 15 'wives' (slaves), and a paedophile, who 'married' a NINE YEAR OLD GIRL when he was FIFTY FOUR. When muslims slaughter innocent animals by cutting their throats and letting them bleed to death, they say "God is great". How sick is that? There is no god, and everybody knows this, so why are a bunch of sicko psychopaths allowed to torture innocent animals because "God told me to do it"? As for Mabs - tell us, why does the BNP website get more hits than any other political parties' site? Why do white people move OUT of areas that YOU move into? Talk about arrogant. Do you know what an 'uninvited guest' is? Do you believe in democracy?

John Radford, says...
2:58pm Wed 20 Feb 08

The 'prophet' of Islam was a mass murderer, multiple rapist, bigamist with 15 'wives' (slaves), and a paedophile, who 'married' a NINE YEAR OLD GIRL when he was FIFTY FOUR. When muslims slaughter innocent animals by cutting their throats and letting them bleed to death, they say "God is great". How sick is that? There is no god, and everybody knows this, so why are a bunch of sicko psychopaths allowed to torture innocent animals because "God told me to do it"? As for Mabs - tell us, why does the BNP website get more hits than any other political parties' site? Why do white people move OUT of areas that YOU move into? Talk about arrogant. Do you know what an 'uninvited guest' is? Do you believe in democracy?

joe, Formerly England says...
3:01pm Wed 20 Feb 08

Mabs wrote:
\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\"Perhaps the silly PC moo in charge of the school would like to introduce sharia law and have compulsory prayer times for all during the school day for all pupils to be \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\'inclusive\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\' with regard to islam! We are NOT a multicultural society. We are a white anglo-saxon society which allows people of other cultures etc, to settle here if they choose to do so( with criteria followed-usually). I find it odd that those from \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\'other cultures\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\' in their own countries are NOT so welcoming to incomers with their own cultures and belief systems. \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\'We\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\' are a little too understanding- and a more agressive approach to incomers with regard to our laws, customs, and belief system is required. Peace\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\" Well Well arn\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\'t we angry angry ? don\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\'t forget the colonial past of this country and how non \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\"white anglo saxon socities\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\" were exploited and there resources exploited and indigenious people abused to bring riches Great Britain. Lets not talk about the slave trade, or Australian aborigies or New Zealand maoris or North Ameraican indians. Or the blase carving up of the middle east or the Indian subcontinent.(not to mention the things done in Africa) The chickens coming home to roost and you will live in a multicultural society whether you like it or not, we are here to stay and we will abide by your laws but we will keep our culture. Maybe if you left the world alone we would not be here ? Read a bit of history before sterio typing.
Stop living in the past, we are in the year 2008, just because our rulers may have commited atrocities round the world hundreds of years ago does not mean people who were not even alive then have to pay for it. Personally I have never had a slave or invaded another country, if you want to carry the guilt for people you never knew or had any influence over, be my guest, but do not expect others to share in your self pity.

Britain is for the British, any visitors who do not like it are free to leave, the do gooders and PC brigades can go with them aswell.

Furious, warwickshire says...
3:21pm Wed 20 Feb 08

Well said John Radford. How is it that there are huge campaigns for fair treatment of animals in food production but Halah meat is allowed in this country?

Mr Man, says...
3:33pm Wed 20 Feb 08

I love a good curry

Mabs, Oxford says...
3:52pm Wed 20 Feb 08

Mr Man
I love Fish & Chips

DanOxford, Oxford says...
4:17pm Wed 20 Feb 08

Weren't the Arabs enslaving the black population of Africa way before 'the white man' arrived?

Slavery is an unjustifiable and unpleasant thing, but then so is altering history to suit one's own ends...

Mr Kipling, spain says...
4:29pm Wed 20 Feb 08

Posted by Mr Man
"I love a good curry"
Me too, but now that we have the recipe?

Mr Man, says...
4:40pm Wed 20 Feb 08

Mr Kipling wrote:
Posted by Mr Man "I love a good curry" Me too, but now that we have the recipe?
And you sir make fine cakes.

Just one thing - do you think you could introduce fish & chips into a school in Saudi for example...I think not. Their Country..Their Laws.

I rest my case me lud.

Mark, Albion says...
12:02pm Thu 21 Feb 08

Whatever happened to packed lunches?

The school should stop being so precious and stop pandering to fads and nutty religions and provide one set meal comprising meat, two veg, and a tasty pudding and any child who won't eat it gets nothing or brings their own. And if the grub can be sourced from within 20 miles of the school - bonus points!

And I do agree that halal and kosher butchery should be illegal. We should also stamp out honour killings, female circumcision, forced marriage, knife crime, gun crime, steamng and all the other joys of immigration. Any immigrant who doesn't like it knows where the door is!

singsong, oxford says...
8:49pm Wed 27 Feb 08

immigrants shouldn't break laws. nobody should break laws.
but that doesn't mean all immigrants break laws, or that we should all be lumped together with criminals, a social burden and a threat. knifings, shootings, drink-related violence can come from native britons, too.
our customs and foods, as long as they are law-abiding, should not be seen as fads or made fun of.
btw, i am not muslim. i am a chinese. i once read someone say in a newspaper that all immigrants have broken the law at some point, and that hurt me. nobody in my family has ever broken the law. we've never imposed our ways on anyone (except for chinese take-out!) we have learned english (ok, maybe easier for us younger ones). please do not write about all of us as if we are unwanted guests.

Your sayYourOxford

comment Add your comment

Register for a FREE The Oxford Times account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.

Please register now or sign in below to continue.




Forgotten your password?
Lyndsy Johnson and her son Dane Lovett, six, with other pupils and parents Choice: Lyndsy Johnson and her son Dane Lovett, six, with other pupils and parents

Sponsored Links


Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »